Affinity Water saves £0.3 million by using Danfoss Drives
VLT® AQUA Drives recently installed at the Chertsey Water Treatment works of Affinity Water are forecast to deliver savings of more than a third of a million pounds in running costs over their 20-year lives compared with the ‘next best’ solution offered for the project. The exceptional efficiency of the Danfoss AC drives results from the use of active filters for harmonic mitigation and a unique back-channel cooling concept
WEDNESDAY, 12 OCTOBER 2016 BY DANFOSS DRIVES
For many years, four high lift pumps at Chertsey Water Treatment works have each been controlled by a 500 kW 12-pulse variable speed drive operating at 675 V. Recently, however, these aging drives had become increasingly unreliable and difficult to maintain. In addition, Affinity Water knew that they were much less energy efficient than their modern counterparts. The company therefore decided that the time had come to replace the drives.
Key requirements for the replacements were that they should deliver the best possible energy efficiency, that they should meet G5/4 harmonic requirements and that they should be suitable for use with pump motors with insulation that was non-compliant with IEC 60034-25 curve B for 690 V inverter use. Having surveyed the market for suitable drive solutions, Affinity Water was ultimately able to narrow the choice to two alternatives. One of these was based on VLT® AQUA Drives with active harmonic filters while the other used drives incorporating active front-end (AFE) technology.
An important benefit of the Danfoss active filters is that they are connected in parallel with the supply to the drive, which means that the motor current does not pass through them. Losses are, therefore, much lower than with conventional filters where the motor current must pass through one or more inductors. Further benefits are that the motor voltage is unaffected by the use of the filters, whereas with AFE drives it is typically boosted by around 10%. Further, in the unlikely event of an active filter failing, the drive can continue to operate as the filter is not directly in the current path to the motor.
In addition, VLT® AQUA Drives with ratings above 90 kW feature back-channel cooling, which reduces the amount of fan cooling power required by as much as 90% compared to conventionally designed drives. This means fewer fans are needed, allowing savings to be made on the energy needed to power the fans and the cost of replacement air filters over the life of the system.
To assist Affinity Water in making a decision between the two alternative solutions on offer, engineers from Danfoss carried out a very detailed comparison of the running costs associated with each. This revealed that the losses with Danfoss 400 kW VLT® AQUA Drives would be 9.6 kW lower per drive than with the AFE alternatives.
On the basis that two of the four pumps would normally be running, the Danfoss drives would, therefore, save 2 x 9.6 x 8760 = 168,192 kWh per year. Assuming an energy cost of £0.10 per kWh, this represents a saving on energy costs of £16,820 per year which is equivalent to up to 20% of the original investment. Over the 20-year life of the system, the energy savings would be £336,380. The reduction in CO2 emissions over the same period was calculated to be 1,776 tons.
This analysis proved decisive for Affinity Water, and the company elected to go ahead with the Danfoss solution. The system builder chosen for the project was Saftronics Controls Limited, a Danfoss Business Partner with extensive experience in meeting the demanding requirements of the water supply industry. Saftronics selected IP20 versions of the drives, rated at 400 kW when used on the Affinity 675 V supply system. The drives were installed in two new motor control centers designed and manufactured by Saftronics Controls Limited, along with du/dt filters to safeguard the pump motors as these have insulation that was not originally designed for use with variable speed drives.
Each of the new motor control centers houses two drives and two du/dt filters. The drives are arranged for efficient back channel cooling. Because of this, only eight cooling fans were needed, compared with the 24 – the number estimated for conventional drives. To make best possible use of the limited space available on the site, the active harmonic filters were installed in existing control panels.
After building and fully testing the control panels at its works in Leeds, Saftronics Controls Limited delivered the new equipment to site, installed and commissioned it. At every stage, Saftronics worked in close cooperation with Affinity Water to minimize the impact of the work on the operations of the water treatment works.
The new VLT® AQUA Drives installed at Affinity Water’s Chertsey Water Treatment Works have now been in operation for 24 months and have performed fully to specification. They are providing accurate and dependable control of the pumps, the harmonic levels easily meet G5/4 requirements, and initial measurements confirm that the predicted energy savings will be achieved.